Florida property claim representation
Mediation notice and appraisal rights in Florida
An insurer’s appraisal demand should be evaluated alongside the policy, the claim history and the applicable mediation requirements. A copied excerpt from an older statute is not enough to decide whether a current demand is enforceable.
Reviewed November 3, 2026. Coverage and available remedies depend on your policy, loss facts and applicable law.
Start with the policy and the disputed issue
Some property policies allow either party to demand appraisal; others require agreement or impose additional conditions. Review the complete policy and endorsements, the insurer’s coverage position and any outstanding duties after loss. An appraisal demand can carry response deadlines, so do not ignore it while researching the issue.
Our appraisal and mediation guide explains the different processes and the records to assemble. Legal questions about compelling appraisal, waiver or litigation should be reviewed by a Florida insurance attorney.
Florida’s statutory mediation notice
Section 627.7015(2) addresses notice of the right to participate in the DFS mediation program at policy issuance or renewal, or when a first-party claim within the section’s scope is filed. The section also contains eligibility and timing provisions. Save the actual notices you received with their dates rather than assuming that no notice exists because it was not included with the appraisal demand.
When the statute affects appraisal as a prerequisite to suit
Subsection (7) addresses an insurer’s failure to give the required mediation notice, and insurer-requested mediation whose results either party rejects. In the circumstances specified there, the policyholder is not required to participate in contractual loss appraisal as a precondition to a breach-of-contract action for failure to pay covered claims.
This provision does not mean every appraisal demand is invalid or that an insured should refuse appraisal without reviewing the record. The exact notice, dispute, policy terms and governing law matter. Our historical Kennedy case summary illustrates a notice dispute under the 2018 statute; it should not be treated as an automatic outcome for a different claim.
Confirm that the mediation program applies
The statute covers eligible personal-lines and commercial-residential disputes. It does not automatically include general commercial property, motor-vehicle or property-policy liability disputes. It also excludes specified matters, including certain fraud or material-misrepresentation disputes, agreed facts establishing no coverage, and losses outside the applicable notice statute. Disputes below $500 require the parties’ agreement to mediate.
Check DFS’s current mediation information for the appropriate program, eligibility, required participants and request procedure. A condominium association should confirm the commercial-residential process and the authority of its representative.
Prepare a useful claim file
- The policy and every applicable endorsement.
- The appraisal demand and the date it was received.
- Notices about mediation and any earlier mediation request or result.
- The insurer’s decision, estimates, payments and requests for information.
- Photographs, measurements, contractor proposals and reports supporting disputed items.
A clear chronology helps the appropriate professional assess next steps. Public-adjuster assistance can organize the loss documentation; legal counsel should decide disputed legal rights. There is no requirement to postpone seeking legal advice until after hiring a public adjuster or attending mediation.
For help reviewing the documented scope of a Florida property claim, contact Experienced Public Adjusters. For legal notices and bad-faith prerequisites, see our civil-remedy guide.
Concerned about a claim payment?
Experienced Public Adjusters helps Florida property owners document damage and present supported claims, with a focus on luxury homes, complex residential losses, condominium and HOA master policies, and commercial property.
Call (888) 881-8416 Request a claim review
Serving Naples, Tampa, Orlando, Daytona Beach and surrounding communities. Find our offices and service areas.
David Dwyer, designated primary adjuster: Florida license W391016. Experienced Public Adjusters: firm license W807213. Representation is subject to a written agreement; no settlement outcome is guaranteed.
